16 May 2008 :: unemployed and/or bored writers please take note: CMG is now hiring

Retconning


XII :: Industrial and its Ancestors
Mark Abraham :: 3 November 2007 |            


I don’t know anybody who only listens to industrial music unless the only thing they listen to is Nine Inch Nails. And maybe Skinny Puppy and KMFDM. And maybe a lot of people wouldn’t even call those bands industrial. And most people aren’t 15 for their entire lives. So let me start by saying that this column is about the long view, where we examine the routes music took to get to a concept of industrial music and a few of the hurdles it leapt immediately after. Of course, tracing industrial precedents and the genre itself is complex because industrial music is as reliant on a kind of gothic, medium-less tone as it is a normally-but-not-always adoption of electronic techniques. By which I mean, the only real gauge for industrial music is whether or not it sounds industrial, combined with some basic concessions to the kinds of electronic acts that paved the ground upon with industrial, komische, and Psychic TV sprung from. So it’s pretty meaningless at the same time that it’s pretty easy to point out.

Which is why talking about industrial music sort of necessitates a historical view mediated by the use of the term in the first place: “industrial music” was, when it was first lobbed around, a term meant to denote the music of artists rostered at Industrial Records. So it really just meant Throbbing Gristle. And no 15-year-olds listen to Throbbing Gristle.

I tend to think about industrial music more as a mix of several different ideas: it is predicated upon ambient concepts of sound without accepting the limitations ambient imposes upon music. In other words, it goes for the same gut-change tonal shifts that ambient goes for even though it’s pretty clear that Nurse with Wound sounds nothing like Eliane Radigue. They share the same headspace though, I think, and the process of recording industrial music, no matter how loud it might be, is similar to ambient: it’s about repetition and minute changes, and both genres are stealing that headspace from minimalism even as industrial kicks the pulse on the back of industry. Industrial is also, normally, influenced by the metallic sheen of krautrock groups like Tangerine Dream and Kraftwerk; however, I’d also suggest industrial reflects the work of krautrock groups it is less associated with. Neu!, for example, in the sense that the most basic industrial music is the roboticization of the index groove Neu! employed, rubbing the creases down until any motion is simply 1s and 0s in lock step. Finally, the most typical industrial music tends to employ the same artistic concepts as the gothic new wave of groups like Bauhaus and Joy Division, cheerfully rankling consumer capitalism with celebrations of sadomasochism, torture, and genocide. 

The albums on this list are not all industrial; rather, they represent an arc of electronic music that supported the growth of an industrial form. This group is bookended by a whole spate of minimalist/ambient/Varése-based electronic composers on one end and a whole new group of composers and bands on the other that include Radigue, Rylan, and probably Lightning Bolt (simplistic, sure, but the point is more that the firm repetition is again being stamped out). Kraftwerk looms over this arc like a silent moon, grinning at the sounds-of-industry that form the rails that Trans Europa Express could carry weight upon.

Oh…and I should probably refer to it as mechanical or something. So: do you like metal?


Silver Apples Silver Apples (1968)

The lyrics and vocal melodies are pure Summer of Love but the electronics bloom with circuitry dissonance. Though the Silver Apples were created when Simeon Coxe got so into his electronics that everybody but the drummer left the band, I’m actually surprised it took so long to link oscillators with psychedelic. Then again, maybe not, since most Summer of Love musicians were dudes obsessed with their dicks (read: instruments). In any case, the result was this, a marvel of an album that set erratic jam dissonance on its head by emphasizing drum work and wild symphonic sine play. This doesn’t sound like industrial music at all until you start to play in its creases, loosening the hippy sthick vocals from their moorings to see the grimey surface beneath. Danny Taylor’s percussion is a riot throughout; it anticipates motorik and, paired with low pitched oscillations, often sounds like inchoate notions of the break. “Oscillations” may be a bit obvious for some tastes, the lyrics simply exploiting the medium to mirror the happy harmony glint of 1967, but elsewhere Coxe taps a bit more into the increasing uncertainty of the US in 1968: the enchanting “Program” sees Coxe intoning “the flame is its own reflection.” The other trick the band exploited incredibly well was to pair dismal music with non-dismal lyrics. “Lovefingers,” which also happens to feature wicked drums from Taylor, glooms under lyrics that might be superficially read as just another “Love the One You’re With”; on the other hand, the glitchy approach makes it impossible not to read into the false promises of sexual revolution offered in the late 1960s, where Coxe is simply going through the motions of free love. Silver Apples may simply have replaced rock instrumentation with a mass of electronics, but the way it did that solidified a process for all kinds of electronic pop music that would follow.



Bruce Haack The Electric Lucifer (1971)

Haack’s traumatic childhood would influence his approach to music in the 1970s, and while Electric Lucifer is generally separated from his proper children’s albums the influence of his rural Albertan upbringing and his studies in psychology are clearly evident. Part gloomy séance and part Robert Munch, Haack implodes age against angst to form a giddy view into the secret world of under-the-bed monsters and closet creepers. And more importantly, Haack was instrumental in beginning to form a critical language for electronic artists.

The album tends to follow Silver Apples in the psyche-rock sense of melody; however, the lyrics are a firm divergence. It’s difficult to view this as just another 1967 cast-off when on “Program Me” Haack asserts, “I am new / program me,” a chilling or hopeful idea depending on how you choose to interpret it. “War” is interpreted as a joyous carnival celebration, Salvation Army band lung-farts squirting everywhere. “Song of the Death Machine” is like that joint the drunk, poor animals always sing in Disney movies. Except this is a chorus of drunk robots. Haack turns the work of the Silver Apples inward, getting more existential and darker in tone, and that’s why Haack sits at the conception of industrial music: he’s bringing the halcyon sixties down to the very personal and very cold reality of the seventies. And in that insular wash of self-created and performed symphonies Haack is constantly drawing the metallic and the childlike together, offering cartoonish perceptions of different ideas -- exactly the exaggerated portraits that industrial music would depend upon. The album follows an arc where Lucifer becomes a sympathetic character in a way that strips him of any evil, but Haack himself also fears he has been cast from heaven; Haack refers to his response as “techmotion.” It’s that simplistic grasp of technology to express emotion that makes this album so forward and unnerving, and places it so squarely in the trajectory of electronic music. Plus, dude used to show this stuff off on Mr. Rogers when that show was still black and white. And plus, while I was getting ready for this column I discovered it was released for the first time ever on CD like just last week.



Lucifer Black Mass (1971)

Mort Garson was born in Saint John, New Brunswick where I grew up. I had never heard of him until I moved away from Saint John. This album should get his picture plastered everywhere, though I suspect the “Lucifer” cognomen has something to do with that. It’s certainly not the relative obscurity, right? Y’know, since this album only exists as used vinyl copies.

The title should give a pretty clear idea of the trajectory of this album. Much of the album plays elegiac, intoned moments against krautrock-like rhythms, stopping brimming activity mid-sentence to replace it with cold shoulders and condensation dripping from held aloft cups. The relationship to industrial music is again indirect; Garson plays with sound in ways that hints at industrial ideas (the use of the Moog for noise effects as much as melody, the uncomfortable pitch bends, the ricocheting blurps in the background) while at the same time heading in the general direction of that ambience. Some tracks get more of the way there, like “Evil Eye,” which sounds like a Nurse With Wound primer, and “Voices of the Dead (The Medium),” which pairs whiny, portamentoed Moog harmonies with thudding percussive accents. And, to be sure, this album isn’t particularly scary, but play the intro to “Black Mass” loud enough and you’ll get similar vibes to Heresie. Even if the song turns out to sound like an Edison Twins incidental. But despite that, given that Garson was limited by early Moog technology as to how dark he could get in replicating host desecration, Black Mass is still pretty chilling in its own way.



Suicide Suicide (1977)

This album is the index patient of music history intersections that are fun and weird to talk about: it’s a no wave album featuring a Silver Apples-style line-up that arguably invented synth-pop and industrial music; it’s Iggy-influenced with members Martin Rev and Alan Vega embracing the art-as-performance mode of musiciality; it’s simultaneously heralded as the advent of no wave and Nebraska (1982); it is damn ugly despite the fact that it was partially written on a fucking Farfisa; it is, in short, the most brutal album the seventies had to offer. And it was produced by Ric Ocasek. Sweet.

Suicide is an intersection as well, caught where the motorik of Hawkwind and the oscillations of Silver Apples meet, with a dollop of krautrock on top of a healthy serving of inchoate punk attitude. And probably some Modern Lovers. But ultimately the album also solidified the place of electronics in rock music by mimicking the movements of analogue instruments in the most robotic way possible. Vega crimps his vocals overtop of Rev’s soundscapes; tracks like “Rocket USA” and “Cheree” are what people mean when they suggest Xiu Xiu sounds industrial. On “Girl” Rev employs a ludicrous pre-programmed bossa nova Casio patch; on “Che” he sprays hiccupping delay everywhere to bring down the horror. The album’s centerpiece, “Frankie Teardrop,” is a mass of pulsing synths that anticipate industrial music explicitly, right down to the minimalist approach to shifts and sighs in the music. Most explicit about the band’s embrace of working class politics and the despair of the late seventies, “Frankie Teardrop” mimics rock and roll to the point where it becomes nothing but a mess of gas valves and mechanical cranking. As Vega disintegrates overtop, man is absorbed into machine, and Rev subtley shifts some delay settings until the thing fades away. This might be the only industrial song explicitly about the people who worked there.



Hosono & Yokoo Cochin Moon (1978)

While his work in Yellow Magic Orchestra was obvious in its connections to Kraftwerk, Haruomi Hosono’s solo work was far more in line with developing industrial themes. This particular set was a collaboration with artist Tadanori Yokoo to create a fake soundtrack to a fake movie based on Hosono’s experiences in India. But more than simply reducing the sounds of India’s enviroment to electronics, Hosono pushes even further to make it all sound mechanical. In a sense, this is industrial music by accident, or an album where insects sound like machine guns, or simply an incredibly important electronic album that fed industrial development.

The compositions featured on this album are split evenly between Hosono and keyboard player Shuka Nishihara; all six tracks are sluiced through a wasp’s layer of manipulation ending up on the other side like towering boards of circuitry. This industrial glaze permeates the album, setting the work of Wendy Carlos and Morton Subotnik comfortably next to Ravi Shankar. As everything crunches and curls into new kinds of calculus, the loose and unpopulated narrative (think a generic Bollywood film) is pushed forth with an intensity produced by the drive of all musicians involved (including several of Hosono’s future Yellow Magic Orchestra mates) to sound entirely different. This album is technically more in line with electronic composition than industrial music, but it’s hard not to hear the machines groaning all over every inch of it.



Throbbing Gristle 20 Golden Jazz Funk Greats (1979)

Notorius though they are, Throbbing Gristle’s sense of humor is what really set them apart. The cover of their classic features the four band members standing in a lovely nature scene; flip the album around and there’s a dead body lying in front of them. On Beachy Head, a popular tourist destination for suicides. And then on the inside, they’re all standing around like punks. And there’s no funk or jazz anywhere.

20 Jazz Funk Greats basically takes all the innovations of the albums that precede it on this list and chops it up to a Neu!-style lope. Often that lope is panned, while Pere Ubu squalls circle in either channel, and various voices speak randomly in the corners. Led by Genesis P-Orridge, the group was more than simply about music: the band featured film and performance artists in Cosey Fanni Tutti and Chris Carter and early sample-tech junkie and future member of Psychic TV and Coil Peter Christopherson. While the live shows are infamous, this album -- said by purists to be their “most accessible,” which in this case actually means “most coherent and developed and therefore best” -- is an example of the band at top form, attacking dance forms in a context of disco and parodying the very idea of pleasure in music. Or, rather, pleasure is presented here as so run-of-the-mill and mechanic that it’s impossible to get excited about it in the first place. And it’s funny, because there are grooves all over this shit, but they’re trapped inside rusty cages that squeak with every head bob, and that’s pretty impressive too: Throbbing Gristle may be the only band in history who have been able to make a wicked dance record that’s pretty much impossible to dance to. On the other hand, every sunglasses-at-night singalong that rocks your eighties retro party owes quiet allegiance to the tone Throbbing Gristle created here: it’s dance music, not for robots, but for every little dark, humdrum neurosis you’ll eventually end up having.



Der Plan Geri Rig (1980)

Geri Reig is as confounding today as when it was released in 1980. Progenitors of the German New Wave, Der Plan’s debut is a mess, as excited about Kraftwerk as reggae, as industrial as it is krautrock. I kind of hate to make this comparison, but there are times where you could be forgiven for thinking you were listening to Ween. On the other hand, the goofy sense of humor that pervades a Ween album is here spun into a manifesto on the possibilities of experimental music, and Geri Reig is therefore coherent precisely because it is incoherent, gleefully cutting the boundaries between music and fuck-ups by intentionally skipping tracks and exploring the boundaries between noise and silence. Talking about individual tracks on the album is kind of pointless; as fans of the Residents, the band clearly understands that, in the context of this album, it doesn’t really matter that the title track is a reggae song, or rather the only point is that the album consumes reggae as part of a process that includes everything else: “Kleine Grabesstille” sounds like computers in mourning; “Hans und Gabi” is industrial comic relief; “San José Car Muzak” is a bracing movement of pitch bent waves overtop a rustling bed of static and arps; “Gefährliche Clowns (Manisch Idiotisch)” sounds like everything is reversed, a gorgeous union of detuned string patches bouncing in pitch unison with an unwinding set of portamentoed sine waves. Under it all, industrial drums pin noise to the audio wall, a process made more conceptual with the track “Ich Bin Schizophren,” which suggests that calling it a mess is just in the eye of the beholder anyway.



Nurse With Wound Homotopy to Marie (1983)

The ways which critics have attempted to describe Stephen Stapleton’s masterpiece are as hilarious as they are varied, but they all get the important part right: this album is fucking scary. And it’s scary because Stapleton is, perhaps more than any other musician, a master of audio space, knowing exactly how to create the kind of nervous, psychotic environment that can only be constructed through heavy tape manipulation. Like, people can’t play this type of shit, an amalgam of minimalist ethos and heavy-weight avant-garde influences.

The original album, only four tracks long, captured a sense of dread by fissuring all kinds of field recordings together. But what’s interesting, I think, is that so much verbiage is devoted to explaining what’s different here that very little tries to find links and touchstones for those who may not want to take a dive after hearing all the hoopla. For starters, it’s impossible not to hear the Varése-inspired percussion of the title track, a glorious turn on the Weill/Brecht approach to absurd horror that is only slightly diminished by a confusing juxtaposition of a title that suggests a change in a woman and a soundtrack that features samples of a young girl discussing blood with her mother. It’s not quite clear what Stapleton’s point is in delving into the horror of menstruuation, although in the context of industrial themes the material realities of sexuality are embraced as much as the spectre of death. I tend to read the track as a play on the hidden realities of female sexuality, and certainly the aristocratic inflection of the maternal voice suggest this is more about criticism of the way young girls are supposed to hide their periods than it is a horror-trope filled indulgence in burgeoning sexuality.

“I Cannot Feel You as the Dogs Are Laughing and I Am Blind” starts the album with a barrage of metallic crunching undercut by sinister drones low in the mix. Again, Stapleton is drawing on minimalist ideas, replacing clarinets with gears. As the track progresses the soundscape shifts to present random voices and dripping fragments, creating a hollow cave from which the rest of the album springs. “The Schmürz (Unsullied by Suckling)” continues industrial music’s fascination with fascism, sucking all the wind out of what sounds like a rally chant and using the results to give scant momentum to an array of bells and industrial noise. The longest track on the album, Stapleton actually constructs a sonic narrative out of a whole slew of samples, including what sounds like a telenova, a bored scholar delivering a lecture, some guitar feedback, a hymnal, some elevator jazz, polka, and a vast array of percussive elements. But it’s the way that Stapleton bridges those elements together, looking back to the prog of Battiato or anticipating the out of John Zorn. Yeah, this album is scary, but it’s also absolutely gorgeous.



Coil Horse Rotorvator (1986)

Horse Rotorvator: the album where industrial, fully formed, finally went pop? This album is clearly a product of industrial sensibilities and ‘80s new wave dance music, not to mention the gay politics of group leader John Balance. And this is kind of what Coil sounds like: Nurse With Wound producing a New Order single with Balance screaming about the anal staircase (or, as they had on pre-Horse Rotorvator single “Panic/Tainted Love,” employed the title of the second to signify the dismissal of AIDs as a gay disease).

The relative obscurity of Horse Rotorvator is frustrating to its fans; there are plenty of great tracks here, though their success might be mitigated by their inculcated oddities (or, less charitably to naysayers, the fact that they’re way gayer than kindred spirits Joy Division). But the album packs its punches in beautiful packages: the gorgeous stringwork of “Ostia (The Death of Pasolini),” the They Might Be Giants-ish turns of “Slur,” the dense meld of opera and groaning samples of “Who By Fire,” the military pomposity of “The Golden Section,” the driving industrial proper of “Penetralia,” or the military band foolery of “Herald.” The album ends with an almost five minute track called “The First Five Minutes After Death” which is an incredibly joyous route of pristine melodies undercut with tense percussion right until it peters out at the end (like, when you reach the light there’s nothing). It’s a scary and depressing thought, of course, but Coil were never about providing happy endings.



Current 93 The Inmost Light (1995/96; re: 2007)

The Inmost Light trilogy is like a raving industrial party to whitch everybody is invited to bring an acoustic guitar. And while Current 93’s David Tibet has always been brilliant with the conglomeration of folk and electronics, his collaborations with John Balance, Steven Stapleton, and Michael Cashmore trip all sorts of Jungian science, locking horns with romanticized psychology and death and all those other goodies industrial artists are so obsessed with. That reissue marking above is actually the first release of the whole suite, which was originally dolled out in three parts: the Where The Long Shadows Fall (Beforetheinmostlight) EP (1995), All The Pretty Little Horses: The Inmost Light (1996), and The Starres are Sadly Marching Home (Theinmostlightthirdandfinal) (1996). The two bookending EPs are marvelous standalone compositions, the former a glassy beast of undulating, unchanging samples (with just the line “where the long shadows fall” repeated endlessly) and the latter a thrilling monologue delivered over constantly nervous shifts and nicely layered vocals. The album between is an actual song cycle that draws melodic themes between tracks (and the EPs) and deals in deliberations on death and religion by exploring Patripassianism concepts of the Christian Trinity. The album is brilliant without being mawkish, sensuous without indulging too juvenilely in the fun of fucking with religion, and incredibly well paced, which might be the most obvious complaint with any other given industrial masterpiece. This is the type of well-conceived dissent that Trent Reznor wouldn’t even begin to understand.